A loaner for the Volt? No thanks

30 November 2011

 

General Motors this week said it would give loaner cars to all 6,000 Chevy Volt owners (should they want them) while federal investigators try to figure out why the electric vehicles' batteries are exploding and catching fire in crash-tests.

 

We won't be taking them up on it.

There have been three car fires (all caused by federal investigators testing crash impact) and two house or garage fires in which a Volt sat in the garage. In the home-fires cases, the Volt has been ruled out at this point either by local fire chiefs or the vehicle owner.

As engineers, you know very well how risk is mitigated with every design–whether it's automotive design, handset design, a PC design or wireless router. General Motors, which, of course stands by its Volt's design and safety, does too.

And we know the difference between provocative headlines ("Crisis deepens for GM's Volt" etc.) and reality. We're still on the road in our Volt, having a great time talking to great engineers about great innovation, and, no, we're not wearing asbestos fire suits along the way.

And as the feds continue to investigate, we may uncover some insight before the investigation comes to a conclusion: In January, we'll tear down a Chevy Volt in Michigan and, in the ensuing five months, we'll report on what we find in our mechanical-electrical explorations that will take you all the way down to the component level, where, no doubt, we'll find some astonishing electronics innovation.

 

 

 

Robert Wyman December 2, 2011 at 2:37 pm

Vote -1 Vote +1

Thanks for your responsible report and not a media hype driven story without data.  A glimmer of hope in the age of easy (worthless) information.

William Ketel December 2, 2011 at 9:15 pm

Vote -1 Vote +1

All of the fires that I have read about that can actually be attributed to a Chevy Volt have been in crashed vehicles that were improperly stored. Both of them. That does not constitute a very large sample, it seems. The fact is that on many occasions a standard lead-acid battery that is subject to penetration by steel body parts in a car crash will also exhibit some very nasty overheating behavior.  Of course it would be quite valuable to have a procedure to follow when the battery is damaged in a collision, but that procedure should be created by one of the people who knows what is inside the battery and how it works.  The two groups who should be forbidden to get anywhere near the process are the media and the legislature, the two groups that know less about it than any others on the planet, it appears.

Oz David December 4, 2011 at 6:45 pm

Vote -1 Vote +1

LOL – I watch the movies, everyone knows cars in America burst into flames as soon as they crash.  What's the problem?

Mark February 5, 2012 at 2:50 pm

Vote -1 Vote +1

I too enjoyed a little level reporting on this issue. No matter our politics, trying to wean ourselves off of foreign oil, and less pollution is something EVERYONE can agree on. Is the Chevy Volt a "game changer"? Not a chance, but it is a first step.
 

feernegeata December 7, 2012 at 11:51 pm

Vote -1 Vote +1

This internet webpage is honestly a walk-through for all of the info you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you will unquestionably discover it.

[url=http://quizilla.teennick.com/poems/23963343/]jordans for women[/url]

Leave a Reply

*Required

* * *
CAPTCHA Image

*

New Products From Avnet

  • HP 3PAR StoreServ 7000

    The world’s most advanced storage platform has extended its midrange offerings, delivering effortless, efficient, bulletproof, and future proof storage to the entire midrange. Store all of your data on a single system that supports advanced features, such as storage federation and automated tiering, and which enables you to start small and grow without disruption.

  • Advantech RISC Computing Platforms

    UBC-DS31 is powered by a Freescale ARM Cortex-A9 i.MX6 dual core processor, with 1GB DDR3 memory & 4GB flash onboard. It has 2D and 3D graphics built in, and supports dual displays with up to 1080p high resolution output on low power consumption.

The Way Back Machine

The Way Back Machine

Connect With Us

Find us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter